American Electronic
Waste Contaminates China and India
August 17, 2005 — By Terence Chea, Associated Press
SAN FRANCISCO — Waste from computers,
televisions and other devices used in the United States is polluting the
environment and exposing workers to toxic chemicals in regions of China
and India where discarded electronics are dismantled, according to a
study released Wednesday.
Researchers detected high levels of toxic metals in more than 70 samples
collected in March from industrial waste, river sediment, soil and
groundwater around the southern Chinese city of Guiyu and the suburbs of
New Delhi, according to the report by Greenpeace International. Dust
from dismantling workshops contained the highest levels of contaminants.
"The extent of the contamination is even worse than we had feared. The
levels analyzed are really scary and very concerning," said Ted Smith,
the founder of the Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition who chairs the
Computer TakeBack Campaign, which promotes responsible electronics
recycling.
Most of the electronics collected in the United States for recycling are
shipped to China, India and other Asian countries where worker
protections and environmental safety standards are weak, Smith said.
The researchers chose to collect samples from Guiyu in China's Guangdong
Province and the Mayapuri and Buradi districts of New Delhi because the
two regions are known to dismantle discarded American electronics to
recover valuable metals such as gold, platinum and silver.
The samples collected from those areas contained elevated levels of
heavy metals used to make electronics including lead, tin, copper,
cadmium and antimony. Researchers also detected the presence of
polybrominated diphenyl ethers, or PBDEs, a type of flame retardant; as
well as polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, a class of chemicals used in
insulating fluids.
The heavy metals and organic contaminants have been linked to a variety
of health problems, ranging from cancer to nervous system damage.
"The high level of contamination caused by unsafe electronics disposal
is a potentially serious threat to workers and to public health," said
Arnold Schecter, a professor of environmental sciences at the University
of Texas School of Public Health. "I think we're fooling ourselves. We
think we're doing the right thing by recycling, but we're harming people
in less developed countries."
Public health advocates said the study demonstrated the need to conduct
larger studies of the impact of electronics recycling on the environment
and people's health.
They called on U.S. lawmakers to pass legislation that would ban the
export of electronic waste to developing countries and require
electronics manufacturers to safely recycle their products after they
become obsolete. The European Union, and several U.S. states including
California, have passed similar "producer takeback" bills.
"The U.S. must step up to the plate and meet our global responsibility
and stop this pollution in other parts of the world," Smith said.
Source: Associated Press |