Dueling Reports


Weīve been seeing a lot of dueling reports about the mounds of debris Hurricane Katrina left behind to steep in yuckwater and bake in the sun, and about how deadly-slash-harmless [take your pick] that wreckage is. For every story like this one from The Washington Post asserting that the pollutants in New Orleansī floodwater fall Well Within The Norm, we see another like this from the Los Angeles Times saying the storm-muck is Highly Contaminated.

 

What seems clear to me is that itīs still too early to draw any conclusions either way, and therefore erring on the side of caution remains the obvious smartest course to take.

 

Thus I think President Bush is right in urging New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin to ease up on his rush to get his city running again. Though I do fervently wish the president would stop doing that urging indirectly through the media. The political gaming surrounding Katrina is beyond stale at this point. Itīs high time for a simple phone call to say, "Whoa, Ray, itīs just too soon. I love your city, too; all of America loves your city. But the all-clear hasnīt been given yet. Wait another week or two, at least."

 

Amid the hurricane fallout, the political pussyfooting and environmental uncertainty, not much is being said about how the immense mass of Katrina-junk will be handled, and where it will all end up. Here is a good article from MSNBC dealing with that topic.

 

Among many other interesting points, the MSNBC story notes that the total amount of debris will dwarf that of the 2001 destruction of the World Trade Center in New York. Which lends credence to a headline I saw at the web site of the satirical newspaper The Onion last week: God Outdoes Terrorists Yet Again.

 

OK, I admit it: Iīm as weary of this topic as Iīm guessing many of you are. So I plan to turn to some non-Katrina news very soon -- like, say, Thursday. I hear theyīre still having a lovely garbage-recycling scandal out in San Jose, Calif.; that trash vigilantes are popping out of the woodwork up in Boston; and that college football fans are attaining heretofore unimaginable new levels of slovenliness.

 

And thatīs just off the top of the heap. A muckrakerīs work is never done.

 

Pete Fehrenbach is assistant managing editor of Waste News. Past installments of this column are collected in the Inbox archive.

Entire contents copyright 2005 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved.

To subscribe or visit go to: http://www.wastenews.com/