Study reveals that ethanol is not a saving grace for oil dependence

21-02-04 A boost in US ethanol-blended gasoline supplies, as called for in stalled energy legislation, would slightly reduce America's oil imports and increase retail pump prices, a government agency said.
Farm-state lawmakers are pushing for production of more ethanol, made mostly from corn, because they say it will help diversify domestic petroleum supplies and make America less dependent on foreign oil. But a new analysis by the Energy Information Administration could provide ammunition for West Coast and Northeast lawmakers who fear more ethanol will raise fuel prices for their constituents and won't have much effect on oil imports.

Pending energy legislation, backed by the White House, calls for the production of gasoline-blended ethanol to jump from the current 2 bn gallons a year to 3.1 bn gallons by 2005. It would rise to 5 bn gallons by 2012.
A review by the energy agency, which is the Energy Department's analytical arm, found higher ethanol production would trim US oil imports by 100,000 bpd, or just 0.8 % in 2010. It would cut oil imports by an estimated 50,000 bpd, or 0.3 %, in 2015. The United States now consumes about 20 mm bpd of petroleum. Imports account for almost 60 % of that.

However, the impact of more ethanol usage becomes more important farther in the future, reducing US crude imports by 230,000 bpd, or 1.2 % in 2025, the agency projected. The agency said its estimated drop in imports by 2025 would be partially because of increased ethanol use for transportation fuels. However, the drop would also reflect reduced demand for gasoline as the result of higher pump prices caused, in part, by ethanol, the agency said.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., has said he plans to bring a slimmed down energy bill up for a vote. The legislation's initial $ 31 bn price tag has been cut in half to please lawmakers worried about budget deficits.

The bill's provision to provide lawsuit protection for oil companies that make the water polluting MTBE gasoline additive, forcleaner-burning fuel, was dropped to win Democratic support. But it remains unclear whether the House would back the Senate's version.
Rep. Joe Barton, R-Ennis, the new chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, said the legislation won't pass in the House if the MTBE lawsuit waiver is removed.

 

Source: Reuters News Service